91 replies to this topic

[smiddaz]

Gordon, on 15 May 2010 - 06:04 PM, said:

Happens in every game... and gets paid 50% of time... and never in the last minute of a final in the forward 50... sorry not never... once

Hold on, so you're saying the free kick is there or isn;t there?

I mean shit, Anthony is grabbed by him arm and pulled back away from the contest allowing an Adelaide player to mark the ball, and you're saying it was not a free kick.

Seriously, wow. I know blatantly bias Adelaide fans who can even admit it was a free kick.

Edited by smiddaz, 15 May 2010 - 06:13 PM.

[Gordon]

smiddaz, on 15 May 2010 - 06:11 PM, said:

Hold on, so you're saying the free kick is there or isn;t there?

I mean shit, Anthony is grabbed by him arm and pulled back away from the contest allowing an Adelaide player to mark the ball, and you're saying it was not a free kick.

Seriously, wow.

Do I really have to re-quote my post?

[woody]

Gordon, on 15 May 2010 - 06:04 PM, said:

nice argument chief

I just can't be *****ed anymore since you keep twisting everything i said. Also Betts did nothing until the 3rd qtr, and then did nothing after 3qtr. So i got my times wrong, but it still remains that Betts did SFA for 3 quarters, and still kicked 3 goals.

[smiddaz]

Gordon, on 15 May 2010 - 06:14 PM, said:

Do I really have to re-quote my post?

Nice argument chief.

By your nice logic, any free kick that isn't paid 100% of the time can be called bullshit when it is paid.

Oh look, he got paid holding the ball. He dived on it and didn't try to get it out, but I've seen it not paid before. That means it's bullshit.

Was the free kick there or not?

[woody]

Gordon, on 15 May 2010 - 06:14 PM, said:

Do I really have to re-quote my post?

You said it was 50% paid, so its either a free kick or not a free kick. I'd say a 50% paid rate would make it a free kick that gets missed a lot.

[Saint]

Sean, on 15 May 2010 - 02:52 PM, said:

Hahn tries hard but I wouldn't mind a Tall centre half like Trav Cloke.

Grossest thing I ever read.

[Matt_852]

Saint, on 16 May 2010 - 09:41 AM, said:

Grossest thing I ever read.

I threw up a little bit...

[mizvrx]

Saint, on 16 May 2010 - 09:41 AM, said:

Grossest thing I ever read.

Saints could use Cloke atm. Especially given the form he is currently in

[Mr. St Kilda]

Id rather Dawes.

[mizvrx]

Mr. St Kilda, on 17 May 2010 - 02:07 PM, said:

Id rather Dawes.

Well, beggers can't be chosers, pretty sure you would be better off/happy with either one..

[Gordon]

IMO Cloke has had a very underrated year... mind boggling to think there is an underrated Collingwood player... but he is... I know he's been doing the team thing for a while now... but he is rarely getting beaten one on one... very very rarely... his kicking is alot better... we've heard about Wellingham, sidebottom, Beams, Ball, Jolly all massive factor to Collingwood success... but when you have a key forward who marks the ball 80% of times the ball goes to him... that is a massive advantage...

Safe to say... he will have a better year than Cam

[Matt_852]

Gordon, on 17 May 2010 - 03:11 PM, said:

IMO Cloke has had a very underrated year... mind boggling to think there is an underrated Collingwood player... but he is... I know he's been doing the team thing for a while now... but he is rarely getting beaten one on one... very very rarely... his kicking is alot better... we've heard about Wellingham, sidebottom, Beams, Ball, Jolly all massive factor to Collingwood success... but when you have a key forward who marks the ball 80% of times the ball goes to him... that is a massive advantage...

Safe to say... he will have a better year than Cam

Cloke has been a great mark for a while now... has been better than average with long shots at goal... but the easy stuff he struggles with... He missed another easy one directly in front on the weekend... thats what would bother the pies supporters.

Previously he has been very inconsistant as well... this year he has been a little better though.

[woody]

Umm pretty sure his marking is as good as ever, what's making him good is that he's actually converting goals, and is setting up better then ever. The only time his contested marking was down was in the early part of last year.

[Gordon]

Never said his Marking wasn't awesome... but he is now Marking everything that goes his way...

[Saint]

Matt_852, on 16 May 2010 - 01:19 PM, said:

I threw up a little bit...

Haha his onto it.