32 replies to this topic

[liam]

so, which player is the best with that number. i have made a list of the contenders and the winners (all the way up to 48 )

1. Clark, Davis, Walker, Ballantyne, McIntosh, Cassisi, Gram, Seaby, Grant = Cassisi
2. Russell, Morabito, Roughead, LeCras, Murphy = LeCras
3. Bartel, Murphy, Lewis, Rawlings, McVeigh = Bartel
4. Mackie, Didak, Gibbs, Watson, Kerr, Cross = Didak
5. Varcoe, Fevola, Maxwell, Judd, Stanton, Mitchell, O’Keefe, Boyd = Judd
6. Ottens, Power, Simpson, Broughton, C.Bolton, Johnson = Ottens
7. Taylor, Adcock, Osborne, Hayes = Hayes
8. Hunt, O’Brien, Kreuzer, Frawley, Wells, J.Riewoldt = J.Riewoldt
9. Kelly, Burgoyne, Swallow, Cotchin, Malceski, Natinui, Gilbee = Kelly
10. Pendlebury, Bateman, Boak = Pendlebury
11. Corey, Young, Firrito, Montagna = Montagna
12. Ball, Sewell, Sylvia, N.Riewoldt = N.Riewoldt
13. Walker, Thomas, Giansaracusa = Thomas
14. Selwood, Birchall = Selwood
15. Hodge, Rodan, Jack, Hudson = Hodge
16. Brown, Pears, Mundy, Grimes, Griffen = J.Brown
17. Byrnes, Gray, Newman, Kennedy, Cooney = Cooney
18. Johncock, Jolly, McPharlin, Guerra, Green, Goddard = Goddard
19. Betts, Connors, Gilbert = Gilbert
20. Johnson, Black, Petrie, Cox = Johnson
21. Mooney, Knights, Barlow, Tuck = Barlow
22. Sidebottom, Moloney, Goldstein = Sidebottom
23. Franklin, Koschitzke, Glass = Franklin
24. Jurrah, Greenwood, J.Bolton = J.Bolton
25. Rutten, Fisher, Hurn, Hargrave = Fisher
26. Douglas, Dal Santo = Dal Santo
27. Edwards, Carlile, Minson = Carlile
28. Bastinac, Schulz, King, Hall = Hall
29. Ablett, Scotland, Pavlich, Harvey = Ablett
30. Scarlett, Waite, Brown = Scarlett
31. Podsiadly, Fletcher, Sandilands, Scully, Kirk = Sandilands
32. Dangerfield, Hill = Hill
33. Houlihan, Rioli, Wonaemirri = Rioli
34. Renouf = Renouf
35. Chapman = Chapman
36. Swan, Davey, Lake = Swan
37. Goodes = Goodes
38. Morris = Morris
39. Drummond, Shaw, Hocking, Stratton, Grundy = Shaw
40. Porplyzia, Jamison, Harbrow = Porplyzia
41. Duffield, Davenport, Foley, Mumford = Duffield
42. Lovett-Murray, Skipper, McMahon, Bevan, Picken = McMahon
43. Houli, Hayden, D.Stewart, Hams = Hayden
44. Enright, Bock, Carrazzo, Milne = Enright
45. Ling, Joseph, Hitchcock = Ling
46. Ellard, Pearce, Webberley = Ellard
47. Blair, Van Berlo = Blair
48. Peterson = Peterson

think i have most of them, i did a lot of research but i may have skimmed over some players.

Edited by liam, 06 September 2010 - 09:06 AM.

[woody]

liam, on 04 September 2010 - 05:39 PM, said:

so, which player is the best with that number. i have made a list of the contenders and the winners (all the way up to 48 )

1. Clark, Davis, Walker, Ballantyne, McIntosh, Cassisi, Gram, Seaby, Grant = Cassisi
2. Russell, Morabito, Roughead, LeCras, Murphy = LeCras
3. Bartel, Murphy, Lewis, Rawlings, McVeigh = Bartel
4. Mackie, Didak, Gibbs, Watson, Kerr, Cross = Didak
5. Varcoe, Fevola, Maxwell, Judd, Stanton, Mitchell, O'Keefe, Boyd = Judd
6. Ottens, Simpson, Broughton = Ottens
7. Taylor, Adcock, Osborne, Hayes = Hayes
8. Hunt, O'Brien, Kreuzer, Frawley, Wells, J.Riewoldt = J.Riewoldt
9. Kelly, Burgoyne, Swallow, Cotchin, Malceski, Natinui, Gilbee =Kelly
10. Pendlebury, Bateman, Boak = Pendlebury
11. Corey, Young, Firrito, Montagna = Montagna
12. Ball, Sewell, Sylvia, N.Riewoldt = N.Riewoldt
13. Walker, Thomas, Giansaracusa = Thomas
14. Selwood, Birchall = Selwood
15. Hodge, Rodan, Jack, Hudson = Hodge
16. Brown, Pears, Mundy, Grimes, Griffen = J.Brown
17. Byrnes, Gray, Newman, Kennedy, Cooney = Cooney
18. Johncock, Jolly, McPharlin, Guerra, Green, Goddard = Goddard
19. Betts, Connors, Gilbert = Gilbert
20. Johnson, Black, Petrie, Cox = Johnson
21. Mooney, Knights, Barlow, Tuck = Barlow
22. Sidebottom, Moloney, Goldstein = Sidebottom
23. Franklin, Koschitzke, Glass = Franklin
24. Jurrah, Greenwood, J.Bolton = Jurrah
25. Rutten, Fisher, Hurn, Hargrave = Fisher
26. Douglas, Dal Santo = Dal Santo
27. Edwards, Carlile, Minson = Carlile
28. Bastinac, Schulz, King, Hall = Hall
29. Ablett, Scotland, Pavlich, Harvey = Ablett
30. Scarlett, Waite, Brown = Scarlett
31. Podsiadly, Fletcher, Sandilands, Scully, Kirk = Sandilands
32. Dangerfield, Hill = Hill
33. Houlihan, Rioli, Wonaemirri = Rioli
34. Renouf = Renouf
35. Chapman = Chapman
36. Swan, Davey, Lake = Swan
37. Goodes = Goodes
38. Morris = Morris
39. Drummond, Shaw, Hocking, Stratton, Grundy = Shaw
40. Porplyzia, Jamison, Harbrow = Porplyzia
41. Duffield, Davenport, Foley, Mumford = Duffield
42. Lovett-Murray, Skipper, McMahon, Bevan, Picken = McMahon
43. Houli, Hayden, D.Stewart, Hams = Hayden
44. Enright, Bock, Carrazzo, Milne = Enright
45. Ling, Joseph, Hitchcock = Ling
46. Ellard, Pearce, Webberley = Ellard
47. Blair, Van Berlo = Blair
48. Peterson = Peterson

think i have most of them, i did a lot of research but i may have skimmed over some players.

Bahaha Ellard really? Webberley easily beats him.

Harbrow and Porps are inseperable, although i think Harbrow has been more consistantly better.

Jude Bolton absolutely buttrapes Jurrah as a complete player.

[bloodstainedangel5]

liam, on 04 September 2010 - 05:39 PM, said:

so, which player is the best with that number. i have made a list of the contenders and the winners (all the way up to 48 )

1. Clark, Davis, Walker, Ballantyne, McIntosh, Cassisi, Gram, Seaby, Grant = Cassisi
2. Russell, Morabito, Roughead, LeCras, Murphy = LeCras
3. Bartel, Murphy, Lewis, Rawlings, McVeigh = Bartel
4. Mackie, Didak, Gibbs, Watson, Kerr, Cross = Didak
5. Varcoe, Fevola, Maxwell, Judd, Stanton, Mitchell, O’Keefe, Boyd = Judd
6. Ottens, Simpson, Broughton = Ottens
7. Taylor, Adcock, Osborne, Hayes = Hayes
8. Hunt, O’Brien, Kreuzer, Frawley, Wells, J.Riewoldt = J.Riewoldt
9. Kelly, Burgoyne, Swallow, Cotchin, Malceski, Natinui, Gilbee =Kelly
10. Pendlebury, Bateman, Boak = Pendlebury
11. Corey, Young, Firrito, Montagna = Montagna
12. Ball, Sewell, Sylvia, N.Riewoldt = N.Riewoldt
13. Walker, Thomas, Giansaracusa = Thomas
14. Selwood, Birchall = Selwood
15. Hodge, Rodan, Jack, Hudson = Hodge
16. Brown, Pears, Mundy, Grimes, Griffen = J.Brown
17. Byrnes, Gray, Newman, Kennedy, Cooney = Cooney
18. Johncock, Jolly, McPharlin, Guerra, Green, Goddard = Goddard
19. Betts, Connors, Gilbert = Gilbert
20. Johnson, Black, Petrie, Cox = Johnson
21. Mooney, Knights, Barlow, Tuck = Barlow
22. Sidebottom, Moloney, Goldstein = Sidebottom
23. Franklin, Koschitzke, Glass = Franklin
24. Jurrah, Greenwood, J.Bolton = Jurrah
25. Rutten, Fisher, Hurn, Hargrave = Fisher
26. Douglas, Dal Santo = Dal Santo
27. Edwards, Carlile, Minson = Carlile
28. Bastinac, Schulz, King, Hall = Hall
29. Ablett, Scotland, Pavlich, Harvey = Ablett
30. Scarlett, Waite, Brown = Scarlett
31. Podsiadly, Fletcher, Sandilands, Scully, Kirk = Sandilands
32. Dangerfield, Hill = Hill
33. Houlihan, Rioli, Wonaemirri = Rioli
34. Renouf = Renouf
35. Chapman = Chapman
36. Swan, Davey, Lake = Swan
37. Goodes = Goodes
38. Morris = Morris
39. Drummond, Shaw, Hocking, Stratton, Grundy = Shaw
40. Porplyzia, Jamison, Harbrow = Porplyzia
41. Duffield, Davenport, Foley, Mumford = Duffield
42. Lovett-Murray, Skipper, McMahon, Bevan, Picken = McMahon
43. Houli, Hayden, D.Stewart, Hams = Hayden
44. Enright, Bock, Carrazzo, Milne = Enright
45. Ling, Joseph, Hitchcock = Ling
46. Ellard, Pearce, Webberley = Ellard
47. Blair, Van Berlo = Blair
48. Peterson = Peterson

think i have most of them, i did a lot of research but i may have skimmed over some players.

1. I'd be tempted to lean towards Gram. Tough one though. McIntosh is also worth a look.
2. Rhyce Shaw needs a mention. He has been better than Mora and Murphy at least. LeCras still wins it though.
3. Bang on.
4. Hanners doesn't get a mention in this number? He's been our 3rd midfielder this year, ahead of McVeigh.
5. Yeah, bang on.
6. Craig Bolton?!?! Yes, he has been injured, but he played a few games this year, and is definitely the best in that number.
7. Yep.
8. Yep, though TDL will be worth a mention next year.
9. Nah, I'd go Swallaw.
10. Yep.
11. Yep.
12. Yep, although I'd argue Josh P. Kennedy deserves a mention. He has had a very underrated year.
13. Yep, though Gia comes close, and Adam Schneider deserves a mention.
14. Yep.
15. Yep. Jack will be better next year though.
16. Yep, no brainer.
17. Yeah, Cooney wins, but no Tadhg Kennelly?
18. Yep.
19. Bradshaw?
20. Good number. Tough to pick.
21. McGlynn needs a mention.
22. I'd take Moloney, but Sidebottom will obviously be better in the future.
23. Yep.
24. Jude Bolton by a country mile.
25. Yep.
26. No Henry Playfair?
27. Yep.
28. Yep. Go the BBBH.
29. Yep. No brainer that one.
30. Yep.
31. KIRKY! Nah, but seriously, Sandi's the one.
32. Dangerfield. More reliable. Hill might end up better though.
33. Yep.
34. Lol, I guess.
35. Yep.
36. Yep.
37. Yep.
38. Yep, but no mention of the great flying Moose, Mike Pyke?
39. Shaw has been kinda ordinary this year... I'd almost give it to Grundy, but Shaw gets it on past performances.
40. Yep. Nick Smith could do with a mention though. Possibly the best small defender/tagger from a purely defensive perspective in the league.
41. I'd take Mumford personally, but I'm probably biased.
42. Dude... McMahon? Bevan, Picken, Skipper and NLM all kick his arse. Picken > Bevo > NLM > Skipper > McMahon.
43. Yep.
44. Yep. What a surprisingly strong number!
45. Yep, no brainer.
46. Webberly.
47. Yep.
48. Yep, not much competition there!

[Roobs321]

Hmm, dont know about No.20, Cox and especially Black with ease over Johnson.

[Rally]

Simon Black over Stevie J any day. But I can't really argue with the rest.

Someone's probably said Jude over Jurrah as well.

[bloodstainedangel5]

Roobs321, on 04 September 2010 - 09:15 PM, said:

Hmm, dont know about No.20, Cox and especially Black with ease over Johnson.

On career, absolutely. On form over the last 2-3 years, including this year (which is kinda how I was doing it), you'd maybe just give SJ the nod. It's a very tough one though, really depends how you approach it.

[Deliriousmouse]

kelly at 9? im sorry but Swallow/Burgoyne every damn day of the week

[liam]

forgot craig bolton from that, i skipped quite quickly over saints, swans, dogs and eagles.

and i do think black is better then steve johnson, mistake there.

but the rest i think are about right, guess you could make a case for j.bolton over jurrah, well more then a case, but jurrahs awesome and yeah.

and BSA, it was scott mcmahon? not jordan? i think that would change your mind a bit, because that number is tough as all players are good and honest, but not great and wouldnt make the absolute best teams 22.

and i have really liked ellards game when he has played, probably not overall better then webberley, but better at the thing he does, which is get contested footy and tag. thats what i think he did when he played?

[liam]

burgoynes 2nd half of the year has been great, and swallow is an absolute future gun, but for consistent, good performances, kelly every day of the week for me.

[Sean]

Adam Selwood wears 37. I think there's a couple of 38s running around.

[bloodstainedangel5]

liam, on 04 September 2010 - 10:11 PM, said:

but the rest i think are about right, guess you could make a case for j.bolton over jurrah, well more then a case, but jurrahs awesome and yeah.

and BSA, it was scott mcmahon? not jordan? i think that would change your mind a bit, because that number is tough as all players are good and honest, but not great and wouldnt make the absolute best teams 22.

Jude Bolton >>> Jurrah. Jurrah is exciting and full of promise, and could well end up better, but Jude has the runs on the board.

And yes, that was my mistake. For some reason I was convinced J.McMahon wore 42. No idea why. Anyway, with that in mind, I'd still be tempted to go with Picken or Bevan. Much closer now though.

[woody]

Blood i understand your mistake J.McMahon = 72 for coburg. I still think Bevan mounts a real challenge to scott even consdiering.

[Saint]

BSA you might aswell just say everyone needs a mention from Sydney.

[bloodstainedangel5]

Saint, on 05 September 2010 - 09:50 AM, said:

BSA you might aswell just say everyone needs a mention from Sydney.

No shit. I did make insinuations of bias throughout the whole thing, you know.

By the way, Pickles, can you please fix up the shitty wink smiley. It just looks like a normal smiley took a fork to the right eye.

[Gordon]

liam, on 04 September 2010 - 05:39 PM, said:

so, which player is the best with that number. i have made a list of the contenders and the winners (all the way up to 48 )

1. Clark, Davis, Walker, Ballantyne, McIntosh, Cassisi, Gram, Seaby, Grant = Cassisi
2. Russell, Morabito, Roughead, LeCras, Murphy = LeCras
3. Bartel, Murphy, Lewis, Rawlings, McVeigh = Bartel
4. Mackie, Didak, Gibbs, Watson, Kerr, Cross = Didak
5. Varcoe, Fevola, Maxwell, Judd, Stanton, Mitchell, O’Keefe, Boyd = Judd
6. Ottens, Simpson, Broughton = Ottens
7. Taylor, Adcock, Osborne, Hayes = Hayes
8. Hunt, O’Brien, Kreuzer, Frawley, Wells, J.Riewoldt = J.Riewoldt
9. Kelly, Burgoyne, Swallow, Cotchin, Malceski, Natinui, Gilbee =Kelly
10. Pendlebury, Bateman, Boak = Pendlebury
11. Corey, Young, Firrito, Montagna = Montagna
12. Ball, Sewell, Sylvia, N.Riewoldt = N.Riewoldt
13. Walker, Thomas, Giansaracusa = Thomas
14. Selwood, Birchall = Selwood
15. Hodge, Rodan, Jack, Hudson = Hodge
16. Brown, Pears, Mundy, Grimes, Griffen = J.Brown
17. Byrnes, Gray, Newman, Kennedy, Cooney = Cooney
18. Johncock, Jolly, McPharlin, Guerra, Green, Goddard = Goddard
19. Betts, Connors, Gilbert = Gilbert
20. Johnson, Black, Petrie, Cox = Johnson
21. Mooney, Knights, Barlow, Tuck = Barlow
22. Sidebottom, Moloney, Goldstein = Sidebottom
23. Franklin, Koschitzke, Glass = Franklin
24. Jurrah, Greenwood, J.Bolton = Jurrah
25. Rutten, Fisher, Hurn, Hargrave = Fisher
26. Douglas, Dal Santo = Dal Santo
27. Edwards, Carlile, Minson = Carlile
28. Bastinac, Schulz, King, Hall = Hall
29. Ablett, Scotland, Pavlich, Harvey = Ablett
30. Scarlett, Waite, Brown = Scarlett
31. Podsiadly, Fletcher, Sandilands, Scully, Kirk = Sandilands
32. Dangerfield, Hill = Hill
33. Houlihan, Rioli, Wonaemirri = Rioli
34. Renouf = Renouf
35. Chapman = Chapman
36. Swan, Davey, Lake = Swan
37. Goodes = Goodes
38. Morris = Morris
39. Drummond, Shaw, Hocking, Stratton, Grundy = Shaw
40. Porplyzia, Jamison, Harbrow = Porplyzia
41. Duffield, Davenport, Foley, Mumford = Duffield
42. Lovett-Murray, Skipper, McMahon, Bevan, Picken = McMahon
43. Houli, Hayden, D.Stewart, Hams = Hayden
44. Enright, Bock, Carrazzo, Milne = Enright
45. Ling, Joseph, Hitchcock = Ling
46. Ellard, Pearce, Webberley = Ellard
47. Blair, Van Berlo = Blair
48. Peterson = Peterson

think i have most of them, i did a lot of research but i may have skimmed over some players.

6. Simpson > Ottens
27. Armfield > Any mentioned
38. Garlett needs a mention
40. ROFL at woody saying Porpz and Harbrow are inseparable when Jamo has had a better year than both
46. Ellard is bang on... came into the side for his hardness... go look at the tackled count and come back to me